Behind bars: use of fences for security and screening of revelers at the São Paulo Carnival increases risk and needs to be re-evaluated, say experts
Experts are calling for a re-evaluation of the use of fences at large Carnival gatherings in São Paulo due to concerns over safety and crowd management.
The recent overcrowding and chaos at the pre-Carnival events on Rua da Consolação in São Paulo have reignited discussions about the security measures employed during large street block parties. Revelers reported feeling suffocated and having difficulty exiting the area, a scenario that has also been observed in other parts of the city, including Avenida 23 de Maio, Avenida Tiradentes, and surrounding the Parque do Ibirapuera. The city continuously uses fences to create enclosed corridors for public circulation and screening, which has raised concerns regarding the safety and comfort of attendees.
A technical note from the São Paulo Military Police indicates that while the use of fences is crucial for maintaining public order and safety during mass events, it must adhere to strict technical criteria regarding planning, installation, and operation. This suggests that the current implementation might not be sufficient for ensuring safety, especially given the overwhelming crowds reported at recent events. Experts emphasize the need to reconsider the current approach to crowd management to ensure the safety of participants during festivals.
Overall, as Carnival is a significant cultural event in Brazil, ensuring the safety of revelers is paramount. Officials and planners may need to adapt their strategies to prevent incidents of overcrowding and to provide a more secure and enjoyable experience for all attending the city's festivities. The ongoing debate highlights the importance of balancing security measures with the lively, chaotic nature of Carnival celebrations.