Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, recently sparked controversy by questioning the viability of the international rules-based order, suggesting it has become obsolete. This statement left many in the political arena stunned, as it implied a shift towards more creative approaches to tackle global crises, potentially undermining established legal frameworks. Her comments were interpreted as a challenge to the democratic and legal underpinnings of the European Union, raising concerns about the credibility of EU leadership in maintaining international norms.

In response to von der Leyen's remarks, António Costa, the President of the European Council, quickly reassured that Europe must continue to uphold the international order based on rules, explicitly citing the principles enshrined in the United Nations Charter and international law. The European leaders collectively emphasized that the integrity of the international legal system is crucial for global stability. Costa's words affirm the collective obligation of European states to adhere to these principles, emphasizing a commitment to international cooperation and rule-based governance.

Despite Costa's reaffirmation, von der Leyen appeared to hedge her statements during a follow-up address to the European Parliament. While she reiterated her unwavering commitment to the same principles Costa mentioned, she did not retract her earlier suggestion to explore alternative methods for addressing global issues. This dual stance raises complex questions about the EU's strategic direction and may lead to a broader discussion regarding its role in the international arena when faced with crises that challenge established practices in diplomacy and governance.