Professor Susan Ostermann, recently appointed director of the Liu Institute for Asia and Asian Studies at the University of Notre Dame, has withdrawn from her position amid criticism from prominent Catholic figures, including a bishop and cardinals. This appointment had already ignited controversy due to her pro-abortion rights stance, which prompted significant pushback from traditionalist groups within the Church as well as alumni and donors of Notre Dame, who view the appointment as contrary to the University’s Catholic mission.

In her withdrawal announcement, Ostermann was praised for her expertise in South Asian politics, and her contributions to both the Liu Institute and the Keough School of Global Affairs were recognized by Marilyn Keough Dean Mary Gallagher. The decision not to proceed with her directorship underscores the ongoing tension between academic freedom and religious doctrine at institutions like Notre Dame, particularly in light of evolving views on abortion rights in higher education and society.

The reactions to Ostermann’s withdrawal may reflect broader cultural and political divides within the United States, especially within the Catholic community. The incident brings to the forefront critical discussions about the role of universities affiliated with religious institutions and their response to contemporary social and political issues, highlighting the challenges they face in balancing tradition with modern scholarly perspectives.