Bishop Kevin Rhoades has publicly condemned the appointment of Susan Ostermann, a known advocate for abortion rights, to lead the Liu Institute for Asia and Asian Studies at the University of Notre Dame. In his statement published in Today’s Catholic, Rhoades expressed that the decision has led to significant controversy and uproar among the faithful within his diocese. He has stated that the appointment contradicts the Catholic Church's teachings on the sanctity of human life, and he feels compelled to voice his strong opposition to this decision.

Rhoades articulated his concerns based on Ostermann's previous writings and public advocacy, which he believes are in direct conflict with the moral teachings of the Catholic faith, particularly regarding the value of life from conception. This criticism not only reflects his personal discontent but signals a broader unease within the Catholic community about the direction of the university, which has traditionally been a prominent Catholic institution. The advocacy for abortion rights, as highlighted by the bishop, raises questions about the university’s commitment to uphold Catholic values in its leadership selections.

The backlash against Ostermann's appointment is indicative of deeper tensions within the Catholic community, especially concerning how modern issues such as reproductive rights are navigated in educational settings. Rhoades's comments suggest that there may be a need for dialogue and reflection on the part of the University of Notre Dame regarding the implications of such appointments on its reputation and on the sentiments of its community of supporters, who hold strong beliefs about life and morality in accordance with Catholic doctrine.