Judge Carlos Mahiques has stepped down from his temporary role in the Federal Chamber of Penal Cassation, where he was involved in overseeing a significant investigation concerning a property valued at $20.8 million, suspected to be linked to Pablo Toviggino, a top official of the Argentine Football Association (AFA). His resignation follows the revelation that he celebrated his birthday at this very property, raising questions about potential conflicts of interest. In his formal communication to the tribunal president, Mahiques stated that his decision was based on "strictly functional circumstances," and notably did not mention his recent party as a reason for his departure.

The property in question has come under scrutiny as part of an ongoing criminal investigation, and Mahiques' involvement in overseeing the case was met with public concern due to his personal connection to the site. His resignation is seen as a necessary step to preserve the integrity of the judicial process as it relates to the investigation into Toviggino's alleged dealings and the illicit activities surrounding the property. Mahiques will continue to serve as a permanent judge on Sala III of the Cassation, ensuring he remains active in the judicial system, albeit in a different capacity.

This situation highlights the complexities and sensitivities involved in cases that intertwine with prominent public figures, especially in sectors like sports where financial dealings often raise ethical dilemmas. The focus is now on the ongoing investigation and how it will proceed without the influence of Mahiques. His exit from the chamber underscores the challenges faced in maintaining judicial impartiality in high-profile cases within the Argentine legal system.