In Alberta, Premier Danielle Smith's immigration policies, currently set for a referendum this fall, are facing criticism from experts who believe they could harm the province's future. The planned changes entail requiring certain immigrants to pay fees for health care and education, as well as making non-permanent residents ineligible for key services until they have been in the province for a year. Such measures are seen as potentially detrimental, particularly in sectors experiencing labor shortages.

Daniel Bernhard, CEO of the Institute for Canadian Citizenship, argues that these policies may exacerbate existing challenges instead of addressing them. He points out that many immigrants fill critical roles in healthcare and education, sectors that are already struggling with high demand. By creating barriers to access services, the province risks alienating a vital workforce that contributes significantly to its economy and community dynamics.

The broader implication of these proposed policies raises questions about Alberta's approach to immigration and its understanding of the value that newcomers bring. As the province grapples with population growth and service pressures, experts like Bernhard emphasize that fostering an inclusive and supportive environment for immigrants is essential. Rather than viewing immigration as an encumbrance, it should be recognized as a valuable resource that can enhance public services and stimulate economic development.