Judge Antonino Di Matteo has responded strongly to Italian Justice Minister Carlo Nordio after being cited by him in relation to criticisms of the High Council of the Judiciary (CSM). Di Matteo clarified that his remarks are being misrepresented and insisted that his consistent stance against the degeneration of self-governance caused by inappropriate political influences makes his warnings about the proposed reform all the more pertinent. He argued that instead of rectifying existing issues, the constitutional changes would increase political control over the CSM and the judiciary as a whole.

In his statements, Di Matteo highlighted the dangers posed by the reform, particularly its potential to undermine citizens' rights and guarantees. He emphasized that the reform, rather than addressing the challenges faced by the CSM, could lead to a more intrusive political oversight of the judiciary, which would negatively impact judicial independence. This reaction underscores the significant concerns regarding political power dynamics in Italy and their potential implications for judicial integrity.

The exchange between Di Matteo and Nordio reflects a broader tension within the Italian judicial system, particularly as reforms are considered in the context of political pressures and public scrutiny. Di Matteo's defense of judicial autonomy strikes a chord amidst ongoing discussions about the role of politics in the administration of justice, revealing a critical intersection of legal reform, civil rights, and democratic values in Italy.