In Italy's ongoing debate over an important reform, former Constitutional Court President Augusto Barbera has openly criticized Napoli's chief prosecutor Nicola Gratteri for his inflammatory remarks. Gratteri suggests that mafias and Freemasons will support the reform, a claim Barbera finds not only unconvincing but also morally questionable. Barbera's comments highlight a schism within the left, particularly among reformists in the Democratic Party (PD) who are rallying against what they see as Gratteri's harsh stance. Barbera, a prominent figure with deep roots in the Italian left, articulated his disappointment calling Gratteri's comments "a disappointment bordering on indecency." His critique suggests that the rhetoric employed by Gratteri risks further polarizing an already divided electorate, as it attempts to categorize voters into simplistically adversarial groups such as 'good' voters against 'bad' ones. In this respect, Barbera's stance serves to not only defend the integrity of legal discourse but also to protect the unity of the left. This exchange underscores the larger implications of political discourse in Italy, particularly as significant reforms are on the table. As different factions within the left mobilize for or against the reform, the rhetoric surrounding it becomes increasingly charged, reflecting broader societal divisions. The potential for electoral repercussions and shifts in political allegiance as a result of such antagonisms cannot be overlooked, as leaders like Barbera strive to navigate these tumultuous waters in support of their ideals.