Luana Carvalho, a writer and podcaster, recently addressed criticism regarding the Portela samba school's Carnival 2026 theme which pays tribute to Afro-Gaucho culture. In a video shared on her social media, she emphasizes the historical significance of the black community in Rio Grande do Sul, arguing that the samba school's theme represents a necessary response to the historical silencing of their stories. She highlights the importance of acknowledging and celebrating the diverse experiences of black individuals from her region.

The theme of Portela's performance, titled 'The Mystery of Prince Bará', focuses on the life of Prince Custódio Joaquim de Almeida, a key figure of African descent who lived in Porto Alegre and contributed significantly to the Batuque, the main Afro-Brazilian religion in the South. Carvalho points out that the story of the black community in Rio Grande do Sul deserves to be told from their perspective, challenging preconceived notions held by those unfamiliar with the culture and history of the region.

Carvalho's advocacy brings to light the ongoing struggle for recognition and representation of black voices in Brazilian society, particularly against the backdrop of Carnival, a time traditionally associated with celebration and cultural expression. Her comments underscore the need for inclusivity and understanding of the complex narratives that exist within the broader context of black identity in Brazil, especially highlighting that there are many ways to experience and embody blackness in different parts of the country.