The discussion surrounding Europe's defense capability in the absence of U.S. support has gained momentum, especially after NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte criticized the notion that Europe can defend itself independently. During a speech at the European Parliament, Rutte emphasized that anyone believing the EU could manage without U.S. assistance is 'daydreaming'. This statement reflects growing concerns among several European nations about their reliance on the U.S. for security, particularly with shifting political dynamics in Washington under the influence of former President Trump.

Rutte's remarks have triggered varied responses among European leaders. While some leaders agree with his assessment, others are pushing back against the notion that Europe must solely depend on the U.S. for defense. This debate highlights a crucial moment for Europe to evaluate its strategic autonomy in defense matters, especially as trust in U.S. foreign policy and commitments wanes. The conversation is further complicated by recent geopolitical tensions and the perception that reliance on U.S. military power is becoming less tenable.

As Europe reflects on its defense posture, experts like Guntram Wolff from the Kiel Institute and Bruegel think tank have joined the discussion, advocating for a serious consideration of how Europe can develop its own defense capabilities. With rising uncertainties about U.S. engagement in global politics, the ability of Europe to bolster its defense apparatus independently could shape the future of transatlantic relations and the global security landscape.