‘The India you grew up in was different,’ Manik Muntashir mocks Naseeruddin Shah
Writer Manoj Muntashir responds to actor Naseeruddin Shah's claims about his invitation being canceled by a university, stating that universities operate independently.
Bollywood writer Manoj Muntashir, known for his work in films like 'Adipurush' and 'Kesari', reacted to Naseeruddin Shah's allegations regarding the cancellation of his invitation from a university. Muntashir emphasized that universities in India function independently and are not directly controlled by the government, which he believes is a common misconception. Although he expressed respect for Shah as a great actor, he also highlighted a perceived difference between the India Shah grew up in and the current landscape.
Muntashir further added that India has transformed and is now a better version than it was in the past, which he referred to as a nation of appeasement. His remarks suggest a shift in cultural and political dynamics, pointing towards a sense of national pride regarding the current state of India. The statement speaks to broader discussions about freedom of expression, artistic independence, and the evolving relationship between public figures and academic institutions.
The controversy stems from Shah's recent remarks, which imply a disillusionment with the current environment for artists and intellectuals in India. The dialogue surrounding this issue signifies an ongoing cultural debate about the place of dissent and criticism in an increasingly polarized society, as figures from the arts speak out on their experiences in today's India compared to previous decades.