Mariah Carey faced substantial backlash following her performance at the opening ceremony of the Winter Olympics in Milan, where many viewers questioned the authenticity of her live singing of the classic 'Nel blu, dipinto di blu'. Critics pointed to her apparent use of a teleprompter and speculated that her vocals were pre-recorded. The online discourse surrounding the event intensified as spectators shared their disapproval across various platforms, adding to the scrutiny of Carey's public appearances.

In response to the backlash, the event organizers expressed bewilderment at the criticisms directed towards Carey, with Maria Laura Iascone, the ceremony’s master of ceremonies, defending the pop star's contribution as 'extraordinary,' and noting that she created a 'magical moment' for the audience. This defense highlights the organizers' commitment to celebrating the performers who contribute to such global events, regardless of the varied audience receptions.

Carey herself has also responded to the criticism, emphasizing her passion for the performance and addressing the public's speculations directly. This incident not only reflects the heightened expectations placed on celebrities during significant events like the Olympics but also shines a light on the broader conversation regarding live performances and authenticity in the age of technology.