Mariah Carey’s performance at the opening ceremony of the 2026 Winter Olympics held at the historic San Siro Stadium in Milan has stirred a wave of criticism from viewers. Many fans and critics took to social media to express their disappointment, highlighting what they described as a clear lack of enthusiasm from the singer during her set. Carey, who is 56 years old, appeared on stage in a silver and white gown, performing a version of Domenico Modugno’s classic "Nel blu, dipinto di blu," also known as "Volare," followed by her own song "Nothing Is Impossible" from her 2025 album "Here For It All."

The criticism has not just focused on Carey’s performance quality but also raised questions about her selection for such a prominent event, given her New York origins and the ceremony's Italian location. Many wondered why she was chosen to perform at a cultural event that is so closely tied to the host country's identity. Social media reactions ranged from confusion to outright disapproval, with users speculating whether Carey had used a playback track due to her seeming inability to reach her signature high notes during the live rendition.

This backlash reflects broader discussions around live performances at high-profile events, where expectations for vocal delivery and stage presence are incredibly high. The diverse opinions and strong reactions from fans showcase how critical audiences can be, especially in the age of social media where feedback is immediate and unfiltered. As the Winter Olympics attempt to merge sport with entertainment, the artists performing at these ceremonies bear the weight of not just their own reputation but also the cultural sentiment of the host nation and beyond.