Arsenal has emerged as a title contender in the Premier League under the management of Mikel Arteta, but the tactics employed have not aligned with the expectations set forth when he took the position. Jamie Carragher highlighted that many anticipated Arteta would mirror the attacking style of his mentor, Pep Guardiola at Manchester City. However, instead of high-possession, fluid attacking play, Arteta has implemented a strategy that relies significantly on set pieces, resulting in goals from corners and free-kicks.

Despite holding a nine-point lead at the top of the Premier League, which could see the club clinch their first title since 2004, this tactical approach has not come without criticism. Carragher acknowledges that others view Arsenal's play as reverting to more traditional methods, prompting discussions about its effectiveness compared to more modern, progressive approaches. The concern is that this reliance on set pieces may limit their overall adaptability and fluidity in matches against more dominant teams.

The ongoing debate around Arsenal’s tactics emphasizes the delicate balance between achieving results and maintaining an attractive playing style. While they are currently enjoying success, the long-term sustainability of Arteta's approach remains to be seen, especially if they are unable to adapt when facing teams like Manchester City, against whom they have struggled in the past. The club's current position provides a unique opportunity to mix efficacy with evolution in their playing strategy.