The article delves into the philosophical insights of Simone de Beauvoir, specifically her assertion that "one is not born, but rather becomes a woman." This profound statement challenges the notion that womanhood is solely a biological attribute and highlights the cultural, historical, and societal factors that shape our understanding of gender roles and identities. By emphasizing the 'becoming' aspect, the piece sets the stage for a critical examination of feminism's inclusivity and the subsequent implications for marginalized groups, particularly trans women.

In the context of Brazil, which tragically reports the highest murder rates of transgender individuals worldwide, the plight of trans women is brought to the forefront. The author argues that the very premise of feminism must be reevaluated if it fails to advocate for those who struggle to exist authentically, such as trans women facing systemic discrimination and violence. The insights from the National Association of Travestis and Transexuais (Antra) underscore the urgency of addressing these biases, as societal rejection and violence often lead to devastating consequences for these women.

The article ultimately calls for a broader and more inclusive understanding of feminism that recognizes the struggles of trans women, particularly in a society rife with transphobia. It serves not just as a commentary on gender identity but also as a rallying cry for change in addressing the societal norms that perpetuate violence and discrimination against trans individuals in Brazil. This inclusive approach is vital not only for the dignity and safety of trans women but for the broader fight against gender-based oppression.