In the aftermath of Manchester United's disappointing 1-2 loss to Newcastle, former star player Paul Scholes did not hold back in his criticism of interim manager Michael Carrick. Scholes took to his Instagram Stories to express his disdain for the team's recent performances, stating, 'Michael definitely has something special, because United have been terrible in the last four matches... good night.' His remarks were particularly sharp and raised eyebrows among fans, especially considering that he has a substantial following of 1.2 million on the platform.

He went on to mention Sandro Tonali, a star midfielder from Newcastle, adding a heart emoji, which appeared to indicate admiration for the opposing player, further illustrating his dissatisfaction with United's management. The critical tone of Scholes’s comments prompted the Manchester United Scandinavian supporter club to label it a 'bizarre message.' This public disapproval is indicative of the increasing frustration among former players and fans concerning the club's direction under Carrick's leadership.

Moreover, Scholes has previously questioned Carrick's qualifications as a manager, suggesting that his experience may not be sufficient for the role. Scholes stated, 'The question is whether Michael has the experience. I know that is a big question,' highlighting concerns over Carrick’s ability to navigate the pressures of top-flight football management. The former midfielder's remarks reflect a broader sentiment among supporters regarding the current state of the team and its leadership in what has been a challenging season for Manchester United.