The article presents a critical view of the Italian trade union CGIL, questioning its commitment to workers' rights, particularly in light of its leader, Maurizio Landini's vocal opposition to the exploitation of gig economy workers, or "riders." Landini is depicted as a figure who denounces various economic frameworks while the CGIL itself reportedly engages in practices that undermine labor rights, such as failing to pay severance to its own leaders. This contradiction highlights a deeper irony within the union that claims to protect workers while appearing to exploit them in certain respects.

Moreover, the piece illustrates a growing disillusionment among Italians regarding the CGIL's ability to fulfill its supposed mission as a defender of labor rights. The author notes that many union leaders, after years of service, expect support from the union in retirement planning, yet are met with disappointing practices that seem incongruent with the union's public stance. The article prompts readers to consider whether the CGIL has truly become disconnected from its foundational principles, leading to cynicism about its role in a rapidly changing labor landscape.

Ultimately, the critique allows for a broader discussion on the effectiveness of traditional labor unions in contemporary economies, especially in the face of increasing gig work and precarious employment. It challenges the CGIL to reconcile its public advocacy with internal practices that appear contradictory to its stated values, suggesting that significant reform may be necessary to restore faith in the union's role in representing workers' interests.