In this commentary piece, the author reflects on a fundamental principle of human rights: they are universal and must be upheld for all individuals, irrespective of their perceived morality or past actions. The piece recounts a personal experience from the author's early involvement in human rights advocacy, highlighting a letter received from an inmate involved in a notorious murder case, which served as a stark reminder that rights should be defended for everyone, not just those deemed 'worthy.' This lesson is critical in the current context of Australia, where public opinion often sways based on an individual's past behavior.

The author then ties this principle to the contemporary situation regarding Australians detained in the al-Roj camp in Syria, where 11 women and 23 children, all Australian nationals, are currently trapped. The article calls for a compassionate approach towards these individuals, arguing that their status as Australians necessitates a responsibility from the government to protect their human rights and facilitate their return. The dire circumstances faced by these citizens highlight the urgent need for reflection on who deserves protection under the universal human rights framework.

Ultimately, the piece advocates for a shift in the narrative surrounding human rights in Australia, urging leaders and the public to recognize that the protection of rights must extend to all, rather than being contingent on individual actions or societal perceptions. This approach would not only affirm the core values of justice and dignity but also reinforce Australia's commitment to international human rights standards.