In his editorial, Yves Thréard critiques Jean-Luc Mélenchon, leader of La France Insoumise (LFI), for his aggressive political rhetoric and tendency to deny any failure in his actions. Thréard suggests that instead of moderating his approach following the tragic murder of Quentin, Mélenchon has only intensified his provocative statements, thus demonstrating a fascination with confrontation rather than constructive dialogue.

Thréard argues that Mélenchon has actively engaged in a process of demonization, creating an atmosphere where he attacks his opponents relentlessly while refusing to acknowledge his shortcomings. This approach, he posits, is characteristic of autocrats who cannot tolerate dissent or contradiction. The critique highlights how this political strategy could potentially backfire, impacting Mélenchon's electoral prospects as voters may grow weary of his tactics.

The editorial calls into question the long-term viability of Mélenchon’s style of politics, suggesting that while it may galvanize a committed base, it alienates broader segments of the electorate who seek more measured and rational discourse after a national tragedy. Thréard stresses the need for political leaders to adapt and communicate effectively, especially in sensitive times, implying that Mélenchon’s failure to do so may lead to significant repercussions in future elections.