The Milan prosecutor's office has meticulously reconstructed the timeline of events from the afternoon of January 26 in Rogoredo, leading to the arrest of Carmelo Cinturrino, an assistant chief of the State Police. Initial signs of discrepancies emerged from a photograph taken by Cinturrino shortly after the shooting, showing the victim, Abderrahim Mansouri, lying face up with dirt on his nose, chin, and lips. Investigators found this inconsistent with his position at the time of the incident, especially since half of his face was covered in blood indicating violent contact with the ground.

The peculiarities arising from the crime scene have raised questions about how Mansouri was killed. Despite being found supine, with dirt on his face while it was soaked in blood, it suggests that he was turned over after being shot. A witness at the scene, who mysteriously did not feature in the initial police reports, claimed that Mansouri was speaking on his phone at the time of the shooting. This account contrasts with the official narrative and adds to the suspicion surrounding Cinturrino's actions, revealing potential police misconduct and manipulation of evidence.

The case sheds light on systemic problems within law enforcement, including issues of accountability and integrity among officers. The implications are significant, not only for the involved parties but for public trust in the police. The investigation into Cinturrino is likely to provoke broader discussions on police practices and oversight in Italy, as it raises serious ethical concerns about the use of force and the treatment of individuals, particularly among marginalized communities.