The article by Mathieu Bock-Côté discusses the recent appointment of Amélie de Montchalin to the head of the Court of Accounts in France, highlighting the widespread approval within the Macron political camp. However, Bock-Côté raises critical questions about the concept of 'competence' that has become a prominent narrative in Macron's administration. He suggests that this term is frequently misused, allowing the technocratic class to insert individuals into positions of power who may not necessarily merit their roles based on public opinion or meritocratic standards.

Bock-Côté argues that while Montchalin may possess qualities that qualify her for her new role, her appointment reflects a broader tendency within the Macron administration to prioritize loyalty and alignment with the technocratic elite over authentic public service. This reliance on the rhetoric of 'competence' has led to a disconnect between the political elite and the general populace, where public sentiments are often dismissed or overlooked, placing individuals in influential positions who may not resonate with the electorate's needs or concerns.

The article serves as a critique of the current political landscape in France, suggesting that the emphasis on competence as defined by the Macron administration undermines genuine democratic engagement and could potentially lead to a lack of accountability within public institutions. In conclusion, Bock-Côté calls for a reevaluation of what constitutes competence in governance, advocating for a greater connection between political appointments and the realities faced by citizens.