The National Post features a selection of reader letters that reflect on the theme of Canadian identity, particularly in response to Conrad Black's piece about searching for a distinct national identity. Many contributors argue that Canadian patriotism is often subtle and not overtly expressed like in other nations. They believe that while Canadians may not flaunt their pride through grand displays, their love for the country is profound and palpable, especially when provoked by external threats or challenges.

One author quoted the famous Canadian cultural commentator Marshall McLuhan, who suggested that Canada uniquely manages to exist without a fixed identity. This notion resonates with readers who feel that Canadian identity is a complex tapestry of values, experiences, and beliefs that cannot always be articulated. They assert that the lack of overt nationalism does not indicate a deficiency of identity; rather, it reflects a different way of expressing pride and unity as a nation.

Overall, the letters illustrate a rich dialogue surrounding Canadian nationalism, encouraging readers to explore their own definitions of identity. The contributions underscore a collective sentiment that while Canadians may not parade their patriotism outwardly, it exists vibrantly within them, shaped by their history, culture, and the challenges they face as a nation.