The article draws a parallel between the 1983 visit of Italian President Sandro Pertini to Paolo Di Nella, a young nationalist who had lapsed into a coma after a violent altercation, and the recent death of Quentin Deranque, another young nationalist. Pertini's compassionate inquiry about Di Nella signified a turn in the national narrative after years of political violence in Italy, contrasting sharply with the current French President Emmanuel Macron's tepid response to the condemnation expressed by the Italian PM Giorgia Meloni regarding Deranque's death.

The author suggests that Macron's reaction lacks the empathy shown by Pertini and indicates a disconnect from the experiences of individuals from different political backgrounds. This is illustrated by the stark differences in how both leaders engage with the media and public sentiment. Pertini's humanistic approach to the plight of a political opponent stands in contrast with the perceived coldness of Macron amidst rising tensions in France.

Furthermore, the article touches on the complexities of Quentin Deranque's identity, which encompassed not merely his nationalist sentiments but also his deep Catholic faith. By exploring both historical and contemporary contexts, the piece prompts readers to consider how personal beliefs and political circumstances intertwine, shaping the narratives that dominate public discourse in times of crisis.