Janice Charette's appointment as Canada's top trade negotiator with the United States has drawn attention due to her controversial role in past government actions during the use of the Emergencies Act. With significant decisions regarding the renewal of the CUSMA pact approaching, her appointment comes at a critical time for trade relations. Charette's experienced background, having served as clerk of the Privy Council and high commissioner to the UK, contrasts with the baggage of her prior actions that have drawn criticism from various sectors. While politicians across the spectrum have shown confidence in her capabilities, notably Jason Kenney, the former Alberta premier, the trust placed in her is accompanied by public scrutiny over the events linked to the Emergencies Act. This aspect of her career is likely to be a focal point of discussion as negotiations progress, highlighting the complexities of political legacy in trade diplomacy. As Canada approaches the renewal deadline for the CUSMA pact, which has significant implications for trade in North America, Charette's ability to navigate the negotiations will be crucial. The concerns raised about her past are not just about her capability but also reflect a broader dialogue around accountability in government. The outcome of her negotiations could influence perceptions of the government's responsiveness and effectiveness in international trade matters.