A new reality TV show, 'Would You Like to Be Amish?' features James, who has been shunned by his Amish community for using a cell phone. The program provides him a path towards redemption by helping six outsiders adjust to the strict and traditional lifestyle of the community. James, who is candid and humorous, serves as a relatable figure for audiences while navigating the complexities of relationships within a community where familial ties complicate dating.

James reveals that dating in the Amish community is particularly challenging because he shares blood ties with almost everyone around him. His struggles are mirrored by fellow participant Emma, who agrees that young people often have to leave the community to find partners unrelated to them. Despite the temptation of the outside world, Emma expresses a deep love for the natural and communal way of life she has experienced. Her apprehensions about the future highlight a common concern within the community regarding outside influences and preservation of their traditional lifestyle.

'Would You Like to Be Amish?' aims to shed light on the experiences of individuals navigating modern challenges within an age-old faith, reflecting broader societal questions about tradition, acceptance, and the impact of modernization on tightly-knit communities. Through the stories of James and Emma, the show seeks to balance entertainment with genuine cultural exploration.