The article from Il Giornale reflects a critical view of Carlo Rovelli's recent writings on China, suggesting that his perspective is overly positive and fails to acknowledge the complexities of the Chinese political and social landscape. The author highlights Rovelli's arguments that celebrate China's achievements in economic, ecological, technological, and educational fields, positioning the country as a moderating force in global politics. However, this portrayal is questioned, as it aligns too neatly with the narrative typically propagated by the Chinese government.

Moreover, the piece specifically takes issue with Rovelli's suggestion that the effectiveness of communism should be reconsidered in light of China's successes. The author argues that Rovelli's viewpoint neglects the realities of a one-party state, where the Chinese Communist Party enjoys absolute control over political processes, often achieving 100% voter turnout through enforced compliance rather than genuine democratic engagement. This points to an inherent contradiction in Rovelli's romanticized account of China, as it overlooks the suppression of dissent and the lack of political freedoms that characterize the regime.

Ultimately, the article serves as a critique not only of Rovelli's arguments but also of the broader trend in Western discourse that romanticizes authoritarian regimes while framing them as viable alternatives to liberal democracies. The implications of such narratives are significant, as they may influence public perception and policy decisions regarding China, particularly in the context of rising geopolitical tensions between the U.S. and China.