Feb 17 • 04:00 UTC 🇮🇹 Italy Il Giornale

Ramy Case, the charge against the carabiniere is mitigated

The charge against the carabiniere involved in the Ramy case has been reduced from homicide to a lesser accusation of excessive negligence in the performance of duty.

In a significant development in the Ramy case, the charge against the carabiniere driving the patrol car during the pursuit that led to the fatal accident has been mitigated. The initial charge of straightforward roadside homicide has been changed to that of homicide with "excessive negligence in the performance of duty." This change stems from a new closure of investigations communicated by prosecutors Marco Cirigliano and Giancarla Serafini, aided by prosecutor Paolo Ielo. This adjustment suggests that the initial assessment of evidence and circumstances surrounding the incident has been revisited, potentially leading to a lighter sentence for the carabiniere involved.

The incident in question occurred on November 24, 2024, in Corvetto, Milan, where a scooter being chased by the carabiniere's unit crashed, resulting in the death of Ramy Elgaml. Notably, Fares Bouzidi, the rider of the scooter, had previously been convicted in a first-instance ruling related to resisting arrest during the pursuit. This point has now played a role in reassessing the carabiniere's actions as being within the line of duty. However, the prosecution still maintains that the carabiniere was too close to the scooter during the chase, indicating negligence concerning the speed of the vehicle and the risks involved.

This shift in the charge reflects ongoing discussions about the balance between law enforcement responsibilities and public safety, especially in high-pressure situations where rapid decisions must be made. The implications of this case could resonate within same incidents of police pursuits, influencing how future cases are handled and potentially leading to discussions on clearer guidelines for law enforcement in similar scenarios.

📡 Similar Coverage