A court in Chelmsford is hearing the tragic case of Esther Martin, a 68-year-old woman who was left in charge of 10 XL bully dogs and was killed in an attack by the dogs. The accused, Ashley Warren, had left Ms. Martin at his home in Essex while he traveled to London to film a music video, despite her limited mobility due to a hip replacement and arthritis. Prosecutors highlighted that Ms. Martin, who stood at 5ft 3in, had restricted movement, raising questions about her ability to manage the dogs.

On February 3, 2024, the day of the incident, Ms. Martin was responsible for two adult dogs and eight puppies, a situation that has drawn significant scrutiny. The trial has focused on whether Warren acted negligently by allowing someone with Ms. Martin's physical limitations to oversee such a large number of powerful dogs. The case raises broader concerns about dog ownership responsibilities and the safety measures that should be taken when leaving dogs in the care of individuals with mobility issues.

The outcome of this trial may have implications not only for Warren, who faces serious charges, but also for future regulations regarding dog ownership, especially concerning breeds that are considered dangerous. The tragic death of a vulnerable individual under these circumstances has highlighted the need for greater awareness and responsibility among pet owners, particularly with breeds that can pose a threat under the wrong circumstances.