STF has never investigated members in office; understand what the law says about the impeachment of ministers
Questioning of Supreme Court Minister Dias Toffoli intensified after his name was linked to investigations involving the owner of Banco Master, but no actual investigations against court members have been established.
The scrutiny surrounding Supreme Court Minister Dias Toffoli has intensified after his name was discovered in records from the mobile phone of Banco Master owner Daniel Vorcaro. This has raised questions about his impartiality in related judicial matters. Notably, discussions regarding the accountability of Supreme Court justices have surfaced, yet no real investigations into these members have been completed, signaling a complex and uncertain path ahead for any allegations made against them.
This week, the Federal Police informed the president of the court, Edson Fachin, about the mentions found in Vorcaro's phone. Fachin interpreted the report as a concern regarding Toffoli's impartiality, subsequently directing the matter to the Prosecutor General's Office (PGR) for further consideration. This action marks a shift in approach, as Fachin chose to involve the PGR and convene the other ministers to deliberate collectively on these serious accusations instead of dismissing the claims outright.
Additionally, in a recent meeting of the court’s ten ministers, Toffoli opted to recuse himself from overseeing the Banco Master case, acknowledging the potential conflict of interest following the revelations. This decision reflects the cautious stance taken by the Supreme Court amid growing public scrutiny and the need for transparent handling of such high-profile allegations, which could have significant implications for the integrity of Brazil's judiciary system.