Lula evaluates that Toffoli needs to leave the rapporteurship of the Master case at the STF
President Lula believes that Minister Dias Toffoli should step down from overseeing the Master Bank case in Brazil's Supreme Court due to concerns about the court's image.
President Lula of Brazil has expressed that Minister Dias Toffoli of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) should withdraw from the Master Bank case, which he is currently overseeing. Lula conveyed this opinion to allies, noting that Toffoli's continued involvement in the investigation could harm the reputation of the court. This perspective has been corroborated by at least three close associates of Lula who spoke with Folha, highlighting a consensus within the president's circle regarding the matter.
Discussions on Toffoli's situation have taken place among cabinet members at the Planalto Palace, although no formal meeting has occurred between the president and his ministers on the subject. The consensus in the government is not to disparage Toffoli personally, but rather to recognize that his position has become increasingly complicated, which could detrimentally impact the image of the Supreme Court. The ideal solution, according to those privy to the dialogue, would be Toffoli's withdrawal from the case to preserve the court's integrity.
Lula emphasized the necessity of finding a 'solution' regarding Toffoli's involvement, suggesting that it would be best for him to step down from the case he is presiding over. This incident illustrates the intricate dynamics between the executive branch and the judiciary in Brazil, as well as the potential implications for the Supreme Court's standing amid ongoing political scrutiny. Lula's push for Toffoli's recusal demonstrates a significant intersection of politics and judicial proceedings in the country.