A murder trial in Perthshire has drawn attention as CCTV footage from the home of 77-year-old David Campbell, the accused, is reported to have malfunctioned on the morning of the alleged shooting. Campbell is accused of murdering 65-year-old Brian Low, his former colleague, on a remote track near Aberfeldy on February 16, 2024. During the trial, jurors viewed certain evidential footage that shows Campbell obscuring a doorbell camera with duct tape on the day of the incident, which has raised questions about the actions leading up to the alleged crime.

As the trials proceed, Campbell has maintained his innocence by pleading not guilty to eight charges, while asserting a special defence of alibi, claiming he was at home when the shooting occurred. The prosecution's narrative indicates a methodical approach to the alleged crime, emphasizing the importance of the CCTV system, which potentially holds key evidence that went silent at a crucial time. This has led to discussions within the courtroom surrounding the reliability of digital evidence and its implications for the case.

The relationship between Campbell and Low, who had previously worked together at Edradynate Estate, adds complexity to the narrative. As the trial unfolds, it appears that the court will need to weigh both the defence's claims of alibi and the prosecution's assertions of premeditated actions, highlighting the often intricate nature of decisions made in both personal and legal realms. This case could influence public perception of security systems and their relevance in criminal investigations, as well as the efficacy of alibi defenses amid troubling circumstances.