When Viewing the Body as a Battlefield and a Machine
The article discusses Susan Sontag's views on illness, arguing for a rational understanding of diseases without the cultural and moral stigmas that complicate their treatment.
The article delves into Susan Sontag's critical exploration of how society perceives illness, promoting a view that diseases should not be conceptualized through metaphors but understood scientifically. It reflects on past beliefs that attributed moral failings to patients suffering from diseases, such as cancer or infectious diseases, and how these views persist in modern times, despite advancements in understanding health as influenced by lifestyle, environment, and genetics. Sontag's work emphasizes that ascribing disease to personal character flaws only serves to stigmatize patients and detracts from the effectiveness of medical treatment.
Through personal anecdotes, Sontag illustrates the profound impact of illness on life, recounting her own experiences with breast and uterine cancer, alongside the loss of family and friends to diseases like tuberculosis and AIDS. These stories highlight societal attitudes that demonize and romanticize patients, perpetuating harmful myths about diseases that can worsen discrimination and social isolation. For instance, terms like 'dirty blood' reflect how cultural stigma can alienate people living with HIV/AIDS, as society grapples with the reality of these conditions under various interpretations.
The article ultimately calls for a shift in perspective, urging readers to separate scientific causation from moral judgment regarding illness. By banishing metaphorical interpretations that color the understanding of diseases, Sontag advocates for a public discourse that prioritizes empathy and rationality, which could enhance societal support for individuals battling health challenges and improve the collective approach to healing and care, rather than condemning those who suffer from various ailments.