Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, has strongly criticized the 'Board of Peace' during a recent interview in Rome, describing it as a colonialist operation. He articulated concerns that the initiative represents external forces making decisions for the Palestinian people, undermining their agency. Pizzaballa emphasized that while there was a request for the Church’s participation in this initiative, it does not align with the Church's mission, which he believes should focus on the dignity of the person and the Sacraments.

Historically, the Vatican has had a fraught relationship with both Israel and the United States regarding the situation in Gaza. The Cardinal's comments highlight a growing divide over how peace efforts in the region are conducted, particularly in the wake of conflicting perspectives on humanitarian assistance for Palestinian communities. He pointed out that even amidst a ceasefire, the suffering of the Palestinian population continues as they face dire conditions, including hunger and cold in Gaza, which he believes must be addressed as part of any genuine peace process.

Pizzaballa's remarks also touch on broader geopolitical issues, particularly relating to the controversial peace plan proposed by former President Donald Trump, which has been criticized for favoring Israel. The establishment of the 'Board of Peace' under these circumstances raises questions about the true intentions behind peace initiatives in the region, especially when they appear to ignore the voices and needs of the Palestinian people. His stance invites reflection on how peace and justice can be achieved in a complex and historically rich conflict, urging a reconsideration of strategies that do not empower local populations.